Behavioural Problems in Huntingtons Disease
by Dr Julie S Snowden
The following article by Dr Julie S Snowden has been
taken from Issue 50 - Winter 1996 edition of the Huntingtons Disease Association
Newsletter (London)
Page 1 |
Page 2 |
Page 3 |
Page 4 |
Page 5 |
Page 6
Denial of Illness
The onset of HD inevitably leads to life changes,
which require accommodation and adjustment from both sufferers and their families. The
process of adjustment is made difficult if the sufferers refuses to accept that there is
anything wrong. To an external observer, the involuntary movements may be obvious, and it
may be evidence that the person no longer carries out occupational and domestic tasks as
efficiently as before. It is easy to assume therefore that these changes must be equally
apparent to the sufferer. The conventional interpretation of lack of acceptance of illness
is that the person is in denial, that the patient at a sub-conscious level is
aware of the reality which he or she refuses consciously to acknowledge. Such as
interpretation can be an over simplification. Research suggests that HD sufferers may not
have normal experience of their involuntary movements: if patients own direct
physical experience does not match with their perception of the illness in
others. There are additional factors which may contribute to non acceptance. The disease
itself can impair the ability to self monitor and to reflect on ones own
performance: sufferers may genuinely be unaware of mistakes which are evident to others.
It can impair too the ability to draw inferences: a persona may be aware of clumsiness or
forgetfulness, yet fail to see the implications of these symptoms for HD. Refusal to
accept illness is not simply a result of obstinacy on the part of the patient - it is a
feature which occurs in some (not all) sufferers as a consequence of the disease process
itself.
Carers and professionals may need to accept that
confronting patients with a diagnosis of HD will not always induce immediate acceptance.
An approach which focuses on specific symptoms rather than diagnosis can sometimes be
helpful (for example, a suggestion that the patient is a bit clumsy and coordination
is not so good may be accepted more readily as a reason for curtailing driving than
having HD). Most patients do come to accept the diagnosis given time.
Behaviour and Disease Progression
Certain aspects of behavioural change become more
pronounced with disease progression. For example, patients patients typically show less
and less initiative over the course of the disease; they show progressively less concern
over their own appearance; they become systematically less aware of the feelings of
others. However, there is not an inevitable association between the length of time that
the patient has been ill and the severity of the behavioural disturbance. Indeed, some
behaviours may become more manageable as the disease becomes more advanced: for example,
irritability and aggression may gradually give way to apathy and unconcern. Similarly,
disinhibited behaviour may be most pronounced early in the disease when the patient is
most active, and diminishes and becomes less of a problem later as the patient loses drive
and initiative. Mood disturbances such as depression tend to occur sporadically and are
unrelated to the duration, severity or progression of the disease.
|